1. English
  2. Polski
Luk Loves Whisky / Subjectively About Whisky

Home » Miscellanea » Whisky Legend 2016

Whisky Legend 2016

Whisky Legend 2016

0

Blind tasting in Warsaw.

Miscellanea Testing / Tasting
(94 points)

Article

Two weeks ago, oh how time flies … I had the pleasure to participate in the Whisky Legend 2016 tasting organized by Daniel and Grzegorz from Whiskymywife.
Leitmotif was Port Ellen versus the rest – only closed distilleries. Convention the same as at Whisky Legend 2015blind tasting. Information about what, in what order we drank was revealed at the end. Below I present my basic tasting impressions, but I didn’t write everything during the event, in effect, records are not able to cast magic of the liquor ;). I also added a score of the whole group and mine.

Here’s the whole set:

Whisky Legend 2016 fot. Daniel Lichota

Whisky Legend 2016 fot. Daniel Lichota

Starter.

Caperdonich, 20 years old, 1994/2014, 46%, Berrys’

N: sweet, citrus, generally nice, a lot of apples, oranges, candied cherries;
T: sweet, grapefruit, a lot of bitter apples;
F: quite long, mineral.

Apples, Calvados.

Score: 3.5/85, group 3.76/ca. 86.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Caperdonich, 20 years old, 1994/2014, 46%, Berrys’

Dram 1 Place 12

Littlemill, 24 years old, 1990/2014, 50.6%, Maltbarn, 158 bottles.

N: mineral, ripe sweet apple, honey, vanilla, cooked apples, pears;
T: sweet with honey, vanilla, and further turns up something to reach the fruit, grapefruit bitterness, grapefruit peel, little tweaks on the tongue;
F: medium length, with apple and honey.

Nose pleasant, taste with bitterness.

Score: 5/88, group 4.85/ca. 88.

Littlemill, 24 years old, 1990/2014, 50.6%, Maltbarn

Littlemill, 24 years old, 1990/2014, 50.6%, Maltbarn

Dram 2 Place 10

St. Magdalene, 32 years old, 1982/2014, 58.1%, Cadenhead, 282 bottles.

N: citrus, lemon, lime, traces of wood, hay, and then mineral, after adding a few drops of water scent became biscuity, buttery;
T: initially sharply and warming, we need water, then came grapefruit and lemon;
F: quite long with elements of sweet and lemon.

Lemons, then biscuits.

Score: 4/86, group 5.28/ca. 87.

lukloveswhisky.pl

St. Magdalene, 32 years old, 1982/2014, 58.1%, Cadenhead

Dram 3 Place 13

Port Ellen, 15 years old, 1974/1990, 40%, Antica Casa Marchesi Spinola.

N: you know immediately that this is Port Ellen, peat is evident, smoked fish, mackerel, coastal, sea air, bonfire from a distance;
T: a little lacking power, peat present, smoked seafood, but the lack of impact;
F: medium length peaty.

Insufficient power.

Score: 4/86, group 4.72/ca. 87-88.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Port Ellen, 15 years old, 1974/1990, 40%, Antica Casa Marchesi Spinola

Dram 4 Place 4

Karuizawa, 29 years old, 1983/2013, 59.4%, cask 5322, 205 bottles.

N: of course sherry, leather seats, sofas, a little smoke, prunes in chocolate, plums, poster paints, motor oil, dried fruit, burnt wood, the interior of the old cabinets, furniture polish;
S: here it is clear sherry too, lots of dried fruit, cough syrup, figs, dates;
F: long with dried fruits, prunes, dates.

Beautiful sherry.

Score: 7/92, group 6.93/ca. 92.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Karuizawa, 29 years old, 1983/2013, 59.4%, beczka 5322

Dram 5 Place 1

Port Ellen 10th, 31 years old, 1978/2010, 54.6%, OB, 3000 bottles.

N: peat, but not so striking, a pharmacy, a dentist from a distance, with a drop of water, lemon, lime, wet soil, hard candy, over time the peat becomes more evident;
T: there are also elements of peat, blunt, with time there is quite a lot of fruit, salty, ashy.
F: long with ash and fruit.

From the beginning peat is in the background, but over the time it gets bigger.

Score: 7.5/93, group 7.43/ca. 93.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Port Ellen 10th, 31 years old, 1978/2010, 54.6%, OB

Dram 6 Place 8

Brora, 27 years old, 1981/2009, 51.3%, Duncan Taylor, Rare Auld, cask #291, 330 bottles.

N: flowers, lemon, calm, gentle, hard candy, grass, quite fresh;
T: I’ve got a little honey, pepper, fruit and a touch of peat;
F: long with elements of sweet and traces of peat.

Score: 6.5/91, group 6.07/ca. 90-91.

Brora, 27 years old, 1981/2009, 51.3%, Duncan Taylor, Rare Auld, cask #291

Brora, 27 years old, 1981/2009, 51.3%, Duncan Taylor, Rare Auld, cask #291

Dram 7 Place 9

Port Ellen, 23 years old, 1982/2005, 55.7%, Taste Still, MH Cask Selection, 240 bottles.

N: quite calm, honey elements, between tougher notes sweetness emerges, lemon then I have traces of peat and smoke;
T: sparkles on the tongue, then creamy, sweet, honey, toffee, over time appears peat;
F: long with remnants of sparks.

Yes, this is Islay.

Score: 6/90, group: 5.89/ca. 90.

Port Ellen, 23 years old, 1982/2005, 55.7%, Taste Still, MH Cask Selection

Port Ellen, 23 years old, 1982/2005, 55.7%, Taste Still, MH Cask Selection

Dram 8 Place 11

Caperdonich, 38 years old, 1968/2007, 51.4%, Duncan Taylor, cask 2619, 166 bottles.

N: some mineral notes, a bit of smoke, burnt wood, mint and further plums, dark chocolate, mango, banana, pineapple;
T: a lot of fruits, peach, pineapple, lots of pepper, a lot of sparks on the tongue, traces of peat and wood;
F: long fruity, still with traces of pepper and wood.

Lots of pepper.

Score: 4/86, group 5.17/ca. 88.

Caperdonich, 38 years old, 1968/2007, 51.4%, Duncan Taylor, cask 2619

Caperdonich, 38 years old, 1968/2007, 51.4%, Duncan Taylor, cask 2619

Dram 9 Place 6

Imperial-Glenlivet, 37 years old, 1977/2015, 53.5%, Cadenhead, 204 bottles.

N: from the beginning delicate peat, chalk, wet chalk, medical, bandages, slightly meaty, wet earth, after addition of a drop of water, quite fresh, more sweet, but with a drop of lemon too;
T: peppery and tweaky, but also with the emerging fruits;
F: long with pepper, peat, waxy and chalky.

Interesting chalk, some pharmacies.

Score: 7/92, group 6.76/ca. 92.

Imperial-Glenlivet, 37 years old, 1977/2015, 53.5%, Cadenhead

Imperial-Glenlivet, 37 years old, 1977/2015, 53.5%, Cadenhead

Dram 10 Place 2

Port Ellen, 25 years old, 1982/2007, 57%, Signatory, cask 2847, 417 bottles.

N: peat, chalk, but also traces refill sherry, medical, meat, steak, traces of sulfur, antiseptics;
T: some pepper, still medically, grilled meat, oranges;
F: long peaty, with traces of fruit.

Steak, traces of sulfur, beautifully.

Score: 8/94, group 7.37/ca. 93.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Port Ellen, 25 years old, 1982/2007, 57%, Signatory, cask 2847

Dram 11 Place 5

Glenury Royal, 32 years old, 1968/2001, 49.4%, Douglas Laing OMC, 258 bottles.

N: intense sherry, meaty, old dusty cabinets, figs, dates, dark chocolate, cocoa, traces of smoke;
T: overwhelming, peppery, but relatively quickly passes, raisins, strong tea, Earl Grey;
F: medium length with raisins and figs.

Sherry, a lovely nose.

Score: 6.5/91, group 6.83/ca. 91.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Glenury Royal, 32 years old, 1968/2001, 49.4%, Douglas Laing OMC

Dram 12 Place 3

Port Ellen, 28 years old, 1983/2011, 54.3%, Reifferscheid, RCC, cask 229, 180 bottles.

N: bandages, antiseptics, in one word hospital, dentist, grilled seafood, sea air;
T: peat, medically, sea, beautifully;
F: very long.

Beautiful peater.

Score: 8/94, group 6.98/ca. 93.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Port Ellen, 28 years old, 1983/2011, 54.3%, Reifferscheid, RCC, beczka 229

Dram 13 Place 7

Port Ellen, 27 years old, 1982/2010, 62.6%, The Whisky Agency, 168 bottles.

N: immediately perceptible very high power, peat, but also traces of biscuits, vanilla, bananas, a few drops of water beautifully opens flavor, provides fruits;
T: large trapped power, a drop of water is needed here, releases a whole, fruits are comming, grilled meat – or maybe it is my tongue ;),
F: long.
High power trapped.

Score: 8/94, group 6.74/ca. 93.

lukloveswhisky.pl

Port Ellen, 27 years old, 1982/2010, 62.6%, The Whisky Agency

It follows that the group’s winner turned out to be Port Ellen 10th, dram 5, with an average score 7.43/93. I rated it at a similar level 7.5 so 93. In my classification on the podium also stood Port Ellen, even three of them, each rated at 8/94: dram 10 Port Ellen, 25 years old, 1982/2007, 57%, Signatory, cask 2847, dram 12 Port Ellen, 28 years old, 1983/2011, 54.3%, Reifferscheid, RCC, cask 229 and dram 13 Port Ellen, 27 years old, 1982/2010, 62.6%, The Whisky Agency. What should I do… I like honest peat.

Thank you all very much for the successful tasting and wonderful company. Until next time!!!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This blog uses cookies files. If you do not agree for using cookie feature, please leave the page or disable cookies in the settings of your browser. ×

This site enclosures whisky informations that are only author's opinions. It is available only for people in legal drinking age who are interested in its content and is not public. Alcohol harms your health. Drink responsibly.

Getting in I declare that I am in legal drinking age and want to get information, author's opinions on whisky.
If you are not in legal drinking age or you do not wish to get whisky informations please get out * The decision to enter the site will be stored in your browser's settings and maintained for a period of 30 days.